Skip to main content
Tail Sourcing
Back to Resources
Comparisons

Hosted vs punchout vs supplier catalog: which one do you need?

Tail Sourcing teamJune 4, 202610 min read
Share
Hosted vs punchout vs supplier catalog: which one do you need?

Teams evaluating procurement catalogs usually ask which model is best. There is no best — there is a fit per category, and most organizations end up running three models at once. The two questions that decide it: who maintains the items, and who is allowed to see the prices.

Availability: punch-out (cXML) is coming soon.

The four models in one paragraph each

Hosted catalog: you create and maintain the items, inside the platform. Maximum control, maintenance is yours. Included on every plan.

Supplier global catalog: the supplier publishes to any buyer at list price. Best for discovery and urgent low-value buys.

Supplier/client catalog: the supplier maintains a catalog holding your negotiated prices, visible only to you. Best for anything contracted.

Punchout: the buyer shops in the supplier's own store and returns with a cart. Best for very large or fast-changing assortments.

Decide by category, not by preference

Run each significant category through this test and the answer is usually obvious.

  • Stable list of items you buy monthly, price already agreed → hosted catalog
  • Contracted category with a supplier willing to maintain it → supplier/client catalog
  • Tens of thousands of SKUs, or configurable products → punchout
  • Category you do not buy often and have no second source for → supplier global catalog
  • Category with no repeat pattern at all → keep it in RFQ, not in a catalog

Who carries the maintenance

This is the question that predicts whether a catalog program survives its first year. Hosted catalogs put the work on your team, which is fine at 50 items and painful at 5,000. Supplier-managed models and punchout move that work to the party that already maintains the data.

If you have no owner for catalog maintenance, do not start with a large hosted catalog.

What does not change between models

In every model the purchase still checks budget availability before commitment, still passes one human approval before the PO and three-way match before payable. Catalogs change where the item and price come from — not whether the purchase is controlled.

Key Takeaways

What to remember

  • There is no single best model — decide per category
  • Volume and rate of change point to supplier-managed or punchout; stability points to hosted
  • Whoever already maintains the data should maintain the catalog
Share

All resources

Opens Calendly in a new tab